This story is taken from the Greater Cincinnati Police Museum.
The Greater Cincinnati Police Museum is located at 308 Reading Road, Cincinnati, Ohio, 45202. Visit their website here.
Albert was born June 6, 1891, to Jacob and Lena (Dalker) Schmitt. He married Edith Applegate in 1909. By the end of 1918, they had five children, and Albert was an Assistant Marshal and first motorcycle policeman for the Village of Cheviot, where his father was the Town Clerk. In early 1919, their fourth child, 2½-year-old Albert Jr., became ill with influenza. He developed bronchitis, then pneumonia, and on February 17, 1919, he died.
On the night of May 27, 1921, Marshal Schmitt, on duty and operating a motorcycle, attempted to stop two speeding motorcycles with sidecars; one operated by Gilbert Ahlenstorf (23) of 512 Oak Street in Elmwood Place, carrying Miss Alvena Brennan (19) of 811 Mound Street in the sidecar. The other was operated by Foster Lloyd (19), carrying Mary Rison (19), also of Mound Street. Marshal Schmitt pursued the motorcycles out of the village and south on Boudinot Avenue into the City of Cincinnati. Ahlenstorf, when he saw they were being pursued, yelled to Lloyd, “Here’s Smittie. Watch me get him!” Just before Werk Road, while the three motorcycles were traveling at 55 miles per hour, he ran into Marshal Schmitt’s motorcycle, forcing it to hit the curb, which caused Marshal Schmitt to be ejected and propelled headfirst into a tree. Ahlenstorf’s motorcycle also went down, spilling him and his passenger. Lloyd stopped and told Miss Rison to get out. Ahlenstorf ripped the license off his wrecked bike. Miss Brennan begged for help for her injured foot. Marshal Schmitt lay broken and bleeding beneath the tree. Ahlenstorf got onto Lloyd’s bike, and both rode off.
Early the next morning, at 3 a.m. on May 28, 1921, Marshal Schmitt died of “shock and multiple injuries.”Marshal Schmitt was survived by his wife, Edith (Applegate) Schmitt (29); children, Alice Schmitt (12), Oliver Schmitt (10), Ruth Schmitt (8), and Freeman R. Schmitt (2); parents, Jacob J. and Lena Schmitt; Edith’s parents, Ollie and Dorothy Applegate; and siblings. He was laid out at his home on Woodbine, and services were held at 2:30 p.m. on Monday, May 30, 1921, at the Cheviot United Methodist Church at Harrison and Lovell Avenues. More than 600 people participated. Edith was so distraught that she could not participate except in the graveside services, where she collapsed. She remained unconscious for several hours at home. Marshal Schmitt was buried at the Bridgetown Protestant Cemetery on May 31, 1921.
A pedestrian who witnessed the crash wrote down the license number and gave it to the first Cincinnati officer on the scene, District 3 Patrolman George W. Berheide. Marshal Schmitt’s injuries included a fractured skull, and he was rushed to General Hospital in Cincinnati. Misses Brennan and Rison claimed not to know the suspects' names, asserting that they met them downtown and accepted their offer for a ride.
Cincinnati Detective Chief Emmett D. Kirgan, Detective Christian Wolf, and Detective Joseph E. Brink investigated. By the end of the day, they had identified Ahlenstorf, and he had not returned to his home since the incident.
Cheviot Police found and questioned Lloyd during the morning of May 29, 1921. Lloyd admitted being the other biker but asserted that he turned off of Boudinot before the crash and did not see it. On June 17, 1921, they swore out a warrant for Manslaughter. On June 21, 1921, Ahlenstorf turned himself in, denied that he ran into the officer purposefully, and was released on a $5000 bond.
Lloyd fled to Florida and, during 1925, married a teenager and had a child. He returned to Cheviot by 1930, and his wife died one year later. Lloyd moved back to Florida and died in 1959. There is no indication that he was ever charged with any crime.
A Grand Jury heard the case, and Cheviot residents were “considerably dissatisfied,” according to the Cincinnati Enquirer when it was announced it had ignored the charge of Manslaughter against Ahlenstorf.
About 1¼ years later, on September 24, 1922, while carrying three other men on his motorcycle, Ahlenstorf ran into a car at Beekman and Arlington Streets. Three more were injured in that mishap, and he was charged with Reckless Driving.
Edith Schmitt was diagnosed with uterine cancer within five years of the death of her husband. She died on June 20, 1927, and was buried next to him. The youngest three remaining children went to live with Edith’s parents, Ollie and Dorothy Applegate.
In 1937 Jacob Schmitt, still the village clerk, was killed in another vehicle mishap. On May 11, 1938, Marshal Schmitt’s son, Oliver, was killed in an automobile crash in Hamilton, Ohio. On July 20, 1972, another son, Freeman Schmitt, was killed in a farm accident involving a tractor near his home at 5572 Muddy Creek Road.
Marshal Schmitt’s death was brought to our attention by David Weeks, an Officer Down Memorial Page (ODMP.org) researcher in North Carolina, and forwarded to us by ODMP CEO Chris Cosgriff. The Greater Cincinnati Police Museum’s Memorial Committee further researched the incident, notified the Cheviot Police Department, and published an account of it on January 25, 2013.
The Greater Cincinnati Police Museum applied to the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial in Washington DC to have him listed on their memorial. The “Names Committee” met on December 3, 2014, and established his eligibility. His name was etched into the Memorial, and he was officially inducted on May 15, 2015.
If you know of information, artifacts, archives, or images of this officer or incident, please contact the Greater Cincinnati Police Museum at Memorial@Police-Museum.org.
This narrative was revised May 28, 2016, by Cincinnati Police Lieutenant Stephen R. Kramer (Retired), Greater Cincinnati Police Historical Society President, with research assistance from Cincinnati Homicide Detective Edward W. Zieverink III, Greater Cincinnati Police Museum Historian, and SORTA Operations Superintendent Philip Lind (Retired), Greater Cincinnati Police Museum Registrar. All rights are reserved for them and the Greater Cincinnati Police Historical Society.